Understanding Feature-Reduction Trade-offs
01 · 2022 — 2024Classical intrusion-detection pipelines often reduce traffic dimensionality before classification, but feature selection and feature extraction preserve information in fundamentally different ways. We compared correlation-based feature selection with PCA-based feature extraction under controlled representation sizes, evaluating detection quality together with training and inference cost. A journal extension (Ngo et al., Cluster Computing, 2024) added systematic analysis across binary and multiclass settings and derived scenario-dependent guidance.
- · Feature selection generally performs better and faster when the retained dimensionality K is sufficiently large, whereas extraction becomes advantageous when K is very small and is less sensitive to K.
- · No single feature-reduction strategy dominates across all operating conditions — the preferred representation depends on the dimensionality budget, computational constraints, and attack-class diversity.